Borderlands Franchise 1-2-3-4 Hello, Vault Hunt Pros and Cons
The Evolution of Mayhem: Borderlands 1 vs. 2 vs. 3 vs. 4
The Borderlands series is a powerhouse of the looter-shooter genre, defined by its billion-gun promise, iconic cel-shaded graphics, and anarchic humor. But which game is the best? The answer often depends on what you value most.
We’re breaking down the evolution of the main series—from the desolate atmosphere of Pandora in the original to the expansive open-world of Kairos in the latest release—to help you decide which one deserves the next spot on your playlist.
1. Borderlands (2009): The Blueprint
The original set the standard for the entire genre, focusing on a lonely, desolate feeling of being a big-game hunter on a lawless planet.
What Made It Different?
- The Loner’s Loot: This game has the strongest atmosphere of isolation. The story is minimal, the Vault Hunters barely speak, and the focus is purely on the loot chase.
- Weapon Proficiencies: Unlike later games, you earned experience in specific weapon types (like Shotguns or Pistols), which leveled up their stats and reload speed, making you commit to a certain gun class.
- Vehicle Focus: Vehicles were central to traversing the enormous, segmented maps.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Pioneering Vibe: The atmosphere and sense of discovery are unmatched. | Clunky Mechanics: Feels dated, lacking the fluid movement of later games. |
| Consistent Loot Flow: Legendary drops are rare, but the base-game loot feels consistently rewarding. | Barebones Story: The narrative is thin, relying mostly on text-based quests. |
| DLC Greatness: The DLC, particularly General Knoxx, is some of the best content in the series. | No DLC Fast Travel: Traveling across the expansive DLC maps is a genuine chore. |
2. Borderlands 2 (2012): The Narrative Powerhouse
Often considered the pinnacle of the series, BL2 amplified everything the original did and gave it a face: Handsome Jack.
What Made It Different?
- The Handsome Jack Effect: The story became the heart of the experience, driven by one of gaming’s most iconic and memorable villains. The writing and humor are sharper than ever.
- Fully Voiced Vault Hunters: The player characters now had dialogue and personalities, making them feel like active participants in the story.
- Slag Element: A new, controversial element was added. Applying Slag to an enemy drastically increased all subsequent non-Slag damage, making it a near-requirement for high-level play.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Best Story/Antagonist: Handsome Jack is a masterclass in villainy. | Endgame Scaling: The Ultimate Vault Hunter Mode (UVHM) made enemies bullet sponges and essentially required Slag. |
| Superior Skill Trees: Deeply customized builds with clear and powerful capstone abilities. | Harder Loot Grind: Legendary drops are much rarer than in BL3 and BL4, requiring dedicated, repeated boss farming. |
| Vast Endgame Content: Raid bosses, Headhunter packs, and Tiny Tina’s Assault on Dragon Keep (a fan-favorite DLC). | Outdated Movement: No sliding or mantling yet, which feels slow compared to modern shooters. |
3. Borderlands 3 (2019): The Gameplay Revolution
BL3 focused less on a single strong villain and more on bringing the core moment-to-moment action firmly into the modern era.
What Made It Different?
- Movement Redefined: The addition of sliding and mantling (climbing ledges) made the gunplay the most fluid the series had ever seen.
- Multiple Action Skills: Vault Hunters were no longer locked to a single Action Skill. They could choose from 3 distinct skills, greatly expanding build diversity.
- Multi-Planet Exploration: The action left Pandora, allowing Vault Hunters to travel to diverse worlds like the swamp planet of Eden-6 and the city planet of Promethea.
- Quality of Life: Features like fast-traveling to any discovered point from the map and the Cooperation Mode (instanced loot at your level) were huge quality-of-life wins.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Toughest Gunplay: The shooting and movement are the tightest in the series. | Weak Antagonists: The Calypso Twins failed to capture the charisma or threat of Handsome Jack. |
| Deepest Build Customization: The combination of skill trees and multiple Action Skills is immense. | Story Pacing: The main narrative can feel like it drags on unnecessarily. |
| Fast Travel Freedom: No more running back to a Fast Travel station to leave an area. | Initial Performance: Suffered from long loading times and optimization issues at launch. |
4. Borderlands 4 (2025): The Open-World Experiment
The latest chapter made the biggest structural change to the series, taking the advanced gameplay of BL3 and dropping it into a seamless, new world.
What Made It Different?
- True Open World: The traditional zones are gone. You now explore the new planet Kairos in a truly seamless environment, eliminating loading screens between main areas.
- Apex Movement: The team leaned hard into traversal, adding double jump, gliding, a grappling hook, and even the ability to swim.
- Grounded Narrative: The story takes a more serious tone, moving away from the comedic overload of BL3 to focus on a new tyrant, the Timekeeper.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Most Dynamic Combat: The expanded movement options make firefights the most acrobatic and fluid yet. | Technical Issues: Initial performance and bug reports, particularly on PC, were significant. |
| Seamless Exploration: No more loading screens while moving between regions. | Invisible Walls: The physical terrain sometimes clashes with the new freedom of movement (e.g., hitting arbitrary barriers). |
| Expansive World: Kairos offers greater environmental and enemy variety than past games set primarily on Pandora. | Visual Overhaul: The graphics are more technically realistic, which some long-time fans feel sacrifices the unique, stylized “comic book” feel. |
The Vault Hunter’s Choice
So, which one should you play?
- For the Classic RPG and Atmosphere, play Borderlands 1.
- For the Best Story and Villain, play Borderlands 2.
- For the Best Gunplay and Build Variety, play Borderlands 3.
- For the Most Modern and Dynamic Experience (and a truly seamless world), play Borderlands 4.
Happy hunting! Which game’s unique spin on the Borderlands formula is your personal favorite? Let us know in the comments!
Post Comment